The Ripple Effect: Exploring the Impact of Mental Health & Suicide Among Health Care Prof in AU
Patricia Maris- Oct 24, 2023
- 15 min read
Updated: 2 days ago
I. Introduction
A.Brief Overview of the Topic:
The COVID-19 pandemic has amplified a profoundly concerning issue within Australia's healthcare system: the escalating suicide rates among health care professionals. This surge in mental health crises, including suicidal ideation and attempts, has profoundly impacted the healthcare sector and the broader community. The real-world implementation of pandemic measures has had economic, social, and personal repercussions, further endangering the mental health of our global healthcare workers. As such, the crisis has escalated the risk factors of suicide among these professionals, leading to an increase in suicide cases.
In this blog post, "The Ripple Effect: Exploring the Impact of Suicide Among Health Care Professionals in Australia," we aim to delve deep into this crucial issue, its broader implications, and the importance of reducing suicidal ideation and behaviours. We seek to explore the multifaceted impact of suicide among health care professionals in Australia, illuminating the ripple effects within the healthcare system. Our focus is the real-world implementation of strategies to mitigate these risks and reduce suicidal ideation and behaviours to foster a healthier and safer environment for our health care professionals.
B. A Comprehensive Roster of Global Health Professionals:
Recognising the diverse range of Health Care Professionals (HCPs) contributing to patient care globally is crucial. This includes those working in both public health systems and private practice.
Doctors: They are often the first point of contact in healthcare and specialise in fields such as Internal Medicine, Psychiatry, Pediatrics, Obstetrics and Gynecology, Surgery, Cardiology, Dermatology, Orthopedics, Ophthalmology, Neurology, and many more.
Nurses: Including Registered Nurses (RNs), Nurse Practitioners (NPs), and Licensed Practical Nurses (LPNs). They provide critical care across all specialties and settings.
Pharmacists: They dispense medications and provide advice on their safe use.
Dentists: Specialise in oral health, with further specialisations like Orthodontics, Periodontics, Endodontics, and Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery.
Physiotherapists: They help patients recover and improve physical function and mobility.
Occupational Therapists: They assist individuals in building skills needed for everyday activities following illness or injury.
Psychologists and Psychiatrists: provide mental health services, including therapy and medication management.
Social Workers: They provide support for social and emotional issues impacting health.
Dieticians and Nutritionists: They provide dietary advice to help individuals improve their health.
Speech and Language Therapists: They work with communication disorders and swallowing difficulties.
Podiatrists: They provide care for feet and lower limbs.
Optometrists: They specialise in eye health and vision care.
Medical Laboratory Scientists: They perform laboratory tests necessary for diagnosis and treatment.
Radiologists and Radiographers: They work with imaging technology for diagnosis and treatment.
Paramedics: They provide emergency medical care.
Chiropractors and Osteopaths: They focus on musculoskeletal health.
Audiologists: They work with hearing and balance disorders.
Healthcare Administrators: They manage healthcare services and facilities.
Home Health Aides and Personal Care Aides: provide individualised care in home settings.
Health Coaches and Wellness Practitioners: They assist individuals in making healthier lifestyle choices.
This list is by no means exhaustive. The healthcare industry is vast and continually evolving, with professionals working tirelessly in various capacities to improve patient health and wellbeing.
C. Importance and Relevance of the Issue:
The role of health care professionals is pivotal, as their mental health directly influences the quality of care they provide, impacting the community's overall health. Thus, understanding and addressing the impact of suicide among health care professionals is essential for their wellbeing and the broader community they serve. This public health concern extends beyond the healthcare sector, as the pandemic has raised concerns about mental illness, suicide, and substance abuse across various populations.
The COVID-19 crisis has significantly impacted older adults' mental health and public health workers, underlining the need for appropriate services and resources. As we navigate these challenging times, the mental health needs of healthcare workers, including burnout, PTSD, and suicide risk, have emerged as significant concerns, emphasising the urgency to address these issues. Through our exploration, we hope to contribute to a more supportive and resilient healthcare system where professionals are better equipped to manage their mental health effectively.
II. Emotional Impact of Suicide on the Healthcare System
A. The Emotional Aftermath of Suicide on the Healthcare System:
The act of suicide by a healthcare professional leaves an indelible mark on their colleagues, the work environment, and the entire healthcare system. The emotional aftermath is significant and widespread, often diminishing productivity and workforce morale. But this distressing real
ity also underscores the urgent need for action. Implementing proactive and comprehensive suicide prevention strategies in healthcare settings is no longer optional; it is necessary. These strategies can help detect signs of distress, provide timely support, and save lives. By taking such action, we can transform our work environments into spaces of resilience and hope, fostering a healthier and more supportive industry for all.
B. An In-depth Look at the Emotional Impact on Colleagues:
When a health practitioner succumbs to suicide, their colleagues are left to wrestle with many emotions. Initial responses often include shock, grief, and confusion. Over time, these feelings can morph into guilt, anger, and possibly depression. Colleagues may be plagued by 'what if' scenarios, questioning whether they could have intervened to prevent the tragic loss.
Health care professionals typically operate within closely bonded teams, akin to families. The loss of a team member to suicide can resonate as profoundly as losing a family member. Feelings of loss and grief can permeate the workplace, hindering individuals' ability to concentrate on their responsibilities. This persistent emotional distress can catalyse mental health issues among staff members, such as depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
C. The Consequences of Productivity and Morale Within the Workforce and Healthcare Industry in Australia:
The emotional burden of suicide within the healthcare industry in Australia extends beyond personal grief and distress. It profoundly influences the overall productivity and morale of the entire workforce. Employees might struggle to focus on tasks, resulting in diminished performance and productivity. They may also require more sick days due to mental health concerns or needing time to process the loss.
Moreover, the aftermath of a suicide can cause a significant drop in morale within the healthcare industry in Australia. The workplace ambience can become sombre, and employees may lack the motivation to perform at their best. There's also the potential for increased conflict among team members as they navigate their grief differently. This ripple effect underscores the critical need for proactive mental health support and suicide prevention strategies in the Australian healthcare sector.
D.Personal Stories Illuminating the Emotional Impact:
Consider the tragic case of Dr. Lorna Breen, a New York City emergency room director who succumbed to suicide in April 2020 amid the COVID-19 crisis. Her death sent shockwaves through her colleagues and the broader medical community, leaving many grappling with the stark reality of occupational stress in healthcare. Known for her energy, dedication, and compassion, her co-workers found it difficult to reconcile their memories of her vibrant spirit with her tragic end.
Similarly, the heartbreaking incident of Dr Choi Ja-wook, a young South Korean intern who died by suicide in 2021 after enduring excessively long work hours, highlighted the dire need to focus on healthcare professionals' wellbeing. His untimely death sparked outrage and sorrow among his peers, instigating nationwide protests advocating for improved working conditions for healthcare professionals.
These unfortunate stories bring to light the emotional toll of suicide within the healthcare system. They serve as grim reminders of the urgent need to address healthcare professionals' mental health and wellbeing, especially during challenging periods like the COVID-19 pandemic.
In conclusion, the emotional repercussions of suicide on the healthcare system are profound and extensive. It not only profoundly affects colleagues on a personal level but also impacts the overall productivity and morale within the workforce. Recognising these effects is vital, and efforts must be concentrated towards cultivating a supportive environment that prioritises the mental health of healthcare professionals. This can ensure patient safety and help prevent self-harm, thereby mitigating the impact of occupational stress in the healthcare industry.
III. Social Consequences of Losing a Health Care Professional to Suicide
The loss of a health care professional to suicide reverberates throughout our society, affecting colleagues, patients, and the wider community. The social consequences are complex and far-reaching, impacting the mental health of patients and the overall wellness of the community served by the healthcare professional.
A. Effects on the Community Served by the Health Care Professional:
Health care professionals, particularly those in primary care roles, often serve as pillars of their communities. They provide medical care, emotional support, and guidance to their patients. When a health care professional dies by suicide, the community experiences a profound loss. This grief can extend beyond the immediate patient population to affect the broader community, as the health care professional's influence often reaches many aspects of community life.
In addition, the health care professional's death may disrupt the continuity of care for patients, particularly in rural or underserved areas where healthcare resources may already be scarce. This disruption can lead to delays in treatment, lack of access to care, and potential worsening of health outcomes.
B. Impact on Patient's Mental Health:
From a patient's perspective, losing a trusted healthcare provider to suicide can be particularly distressing. For many patients, their healthcare provider is a stable, reassuring presence, particularly those with chronic or severe health conditions. The sudden loss of this figure can trigger feelings of abandonment, anxiety, and depression, potentially exacerbating existing mental health issues.
Patients may also grapple with feelings of guilt, wondering if they could have done something to prevent their healthcare provider's suicide. These feelings can result in self-blame, contributing to increased psychological distress. Furthermore, the stigma surrounding suicide may deter patients from seeking support for these feelings, leading to unaddressed grief and potential mental health deterioration.
C. Relevant Examples Highlighting Social Consequences:
Consider the case of a small town losing its only general practitioner to suicide. This tragic event would likely send shockwaves through the community as residents grapple with losing a key figure in their healthcare system. Patients may find themselves without immediate access to necessary medical care, creating anxiety and uncertainty.
Another example is a mental health clinic where a therapist dies by suicide. Many patients dealing with mental health struggles suddenly face losing their trusted counsellor. The impact of this loss on their mental health could be devastating, potentially leading to relapses or worsening of symptoms.
In conclusion, the social consequences of losing a health care professional to suicide are profound and far-reaching. They affect colleagues within the healthcare system, patients, and the broader community. It underscores the importance of proactive mental health support and resources for health care professionals for their wellbeing and communities.
IV. Economic Repercussions of Suicide Among Healthcare Professionals
The economic impact of suicide among Health Care Professionals is profound, with repercussions beyond the immediate emotional toll, including significant financial costs. These costs are multifaceted and encompass aspects such as hiring and training replacements, potential increases in insurance premiums, and the broader economic burden of suicide and suicide attempts.
A. Financial Costs Associated with Hiring and Training Replacements:
When a healthcare professional dies by suicide, one of the immediate challenges organisations face is finding a replacement. The hiring process in healthcare is both expensive and time-consuming. According to a study from ADP, hiring a new employee costs employers an average of $4,129. But the financial strain doesn't end there. Once a new hire is onboarded, organisations must invest in training to ensure the individual can provide the level of care expected. Training healthcare employees can be substantial, adding to the overall expense.
Furthermore, the cost of recruitment can be even higher for specialised roles. According to the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), the average cost per hire can reach $4,700. These costs can significantly impact the financial stability of healthcare organisations, especially those operating on tight budgets.
B. Potential Increases in Insurance Premiums Due to Suicide Rates:
Insurance premiums could increase if suicide rates among health care professionals become a concerning trend. Health and life insurance companies often adjust their premium rates based on risk factors. If suicides among healthcare professionals increase, it may lead to higher premiums as insurers attempt to balance the increased risk.
C. Citation of Reports on the Economic Burden of Suicide and Suicide Attempts:
Suicide and suicide attempts have a significant economic burden. A report by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that suicides and suicide attempts cost the nation almost $70 billion annually in lifetime medical and work-loss costs. This estimate considers the potential earnings lost due to premature death by suicide and the cost of medical care associated with suicide attempts.
When a health care professional dies by suicide, the economic loss is even more pronounced. These individuals are highly trained professionals whose skills are in high demand. The loss of their contribution to the healthcare system and the costs associated with replacing them contribute to the significant economic burden of suicide among health care professionals.
In conclusion, the economic repercussions of suicide among health care professionals are significant and multifaceted. They include the direct costs of hiring and training replacements, potential increases in insurance premiums, and the broader economic impact of suicide and suicide attempts.
V. Innovative Approaches to Managing the Aftermath: Harnessing Digital Technologies for Mental Health and Supporting Remaining Staff
The devastating occurrence of suicide within a healthcare department leaves a profound impact on all parties involved. It disrupts the department's functioning, affects patients' trust, and potentially harms its reputation in the community.
A. Decrease in Patient Trust and Its Effect on Quality of Care:
Trust is a vital component of the patient-healthcare provider relationship. When a health care professional dies by suicide, it can shake the foundation of this trust, especially if the deceased was directly involved in patient care. Patients may question the quality of care and fear their health could be compromised. This decrease in trust can lead to increased anxiety among patients, reduced compliance with treatment plans, and potentially poorer health outcomes.
Innovative management strategies are essential in the wake of such a heartbreaking event. The department leadership should foster an environment of open communication about the incident while honouring the privacy and dignity of the departed.
One key strategy is leveraging digital technologies for mental health support. These tools can provide the necessary resources to help the remaining staff navigate their grief. This could involve offering digital counselling services, providing online resources for grief management, and creating virtual spaces for team discussions to process the event.
Maintaining continuity of care for patients is another crucial aspect that requires innovative approaches. The department needs to have a plan in place to ensure patients continue receiving much-needed care. This could mean redistributing the caseload among existing staff or hiring temporary providers until a permanent replacement is secured. Digital technologies can play a vital role in this process, enabling seamless communication and coordination among staff.'
B. Potential Reputational Damage:
The suicide of a health care professional can also potentially damage the department's reputation. This could result in a decrease in patient numbers, negatively impacting the financial stability of the department. To mitigate this, the department should communicate transparently with patients and the broader community about the steps to ensure continued high-quality care. This might include sharing information about additional staff training, increased mental health support for providers, and any changes to improve patient care.
In conclusion, the aftermath of a health care professional's suicide is a complex and challenging time for a department. It requires careful management to support remaining staff, ensure continuity of care for patients, and maintain the trust of the community.
VI. The Multifaceted Impact of Suicide in the Healthcare Industry
The impact of suicide within the healthcare industry is profound and multifaceted, stretching beyond the immediate loss to encompass emotional, social, and economic consequences.
The emotional toll is heavy, affecting colleagues who grieve their lost co-workers and patients who may have formed close bonds with the health care professional. This emotional distress can decrease productivity and morale within the workforce, further impacting patient care quality.
Socially, the suicide of a health care professional can shake the trust of patients and the community in the healthcare system. This can increase patient anxiety and potential reputational damage for the department or institution involved.
Economically, the costs are also significant. These include the financial burden associated with hiring and training replacements, potential increases in insurance premiums, and the broader economic impact of suicide and suicide attempts.
Given these wide-ranging impacts, it's clear that suicide prevention strategies and mental health support within the healthcare workforce are not just desirable but essential. Efforts should be made to ensure health care professionals can access mental health services and support. Furthermore, organisations should foster a culture of openness about mental health, encouraging staff to seek help when needed.
In conclusion, the impact of suicide in the healthcare industry is far-reaching, underlining the critical need for proactive mental health support and robust suicide prevention strategies within this sector.
VII. Taking the Lead: Pioneering Mental Health Support and Prevention Strategies in the Healthcare Industry of Australia - A Call for Action
The impact of suicide within the healthcare industry is far-reaching, affecting not only the emotional wellbeing of colleagues and patients but also the social trust and economic stability of healthcare institutions. However, we are not powerless in the face of this crisis. Evidence-based strategies and robust mental health support systems provide potent tools to counteract these effects. It's time for Australia to take the lead, pioneering mental health support and prevention strategies in the healthcare industry - a call for action that is both urgent and necessary.
A systematic review published in the American Journal of Psychiatry underscores the importance of using proven suicide prevention methods. The Zero Suicide Model is another evidence-based approach that has shown promise in clinical settings, emphasising suicide prevention at every level of care.
Cutting-edge programs such as the e7Doctors wellness online initiative are taking proactive measures to tackle wellness challenges. Presently in its pilot phase at two leading Australian universities, this program adopts a WHOLE-istic perspective towards wellness. It emphasises eight critical dimensions of life, applying the 80/20 rule and the principle of dedicating 100 minutes per year to gradually restore balance in your life over a span of 54 weeks.
However, implementing such programs requires advocacy and support from the healthcare community. Mental health support for healthcare workers is not optional; it's necessary for the welfare of health care professionals and, by extension, the patients they serve. Within the healthcare industry in Australia, we need to champion mental health initiatives in our workplaces and push for adopting these evidence-based practices.
Let's acknowledge the significant role mental health plays in the overall wellbeing of health care professionals. Let's advocate for mental health support in our workplaces, implement evidence-based prevention strategies, and create an environment where healthcare professionals can thrive professionally and personally. It's time for the healthcare industry in Australia to be a pioneer in this much-needed change.
VIII. Conclusion:
In conclusion, the challenge we face in addressing healthcare professional suicides is substantial, casting a long shadow over the healthcare industry's emotional, social, and economic aspects. Yet, within this profound complexity lies an equally potent force for transformation. Our potential for positive change is immense. By embracing evidence-based strategies for suicide prevention and advocating fervently for robust mental health support, we can begin to turn the tide. The repercussions of such tragedies underscore the urgency of our task, highlighting the critical need for comprehensive wellness initiatives within the healthcare workforce. As we navigate this path, remember that our ultimate goal is to heal bodies and foster a healthier, more supportive environment where every healthcare professional can thrive. In doing so, we strengthen the very foundations of our healthcare industry, ensuring it remains a beacon of hope and healing for all.
Together, we can embrace a healthier, happier lifestyle. 💪🌱 #StartYourWellnessJourney
Unlock Your Wellness Potential:
A Deep Dive into Self-Understanding with e7D-MarisGraph.
Understanding ourselves is the first crucial step in the pursuit of optimal wellbeing. I'm thrilled to introduce you to an innovative tool that can help you do just that –the e7D-Maris Graph.
The e7D-Maris Graph is a cutting-edge wellness barometer designed to evaluate your wellbeing comprehensively. It assesses eight critical pillars of wellness, such as sexual wellness, willpower, breathing, thoughts, nutrition, sleep, and how well your hydration is, offering valuable insights into your current state of health.
Knowing where you stand in these areas can empower you to take control of your wellbeing, identify areas for improvement, and guide you towards fulfilling your highest potential. Whether you're a wellness beginner or a seasoned pro looking to fine-tune your routine, the e7D-Maris Graph can provide invaluable guidance tailored to your needs.
So, are you ready to dive deeper into your wellness journey? Here's your chance!
Unleash Your Potential with e7D-MarisGraph Now! FREE enter coupon MG#20
Unlock the power of real-time wellbeing insight with the e7D-MarisGraph. This revolutionary tool shows you where your health stands, helping you take actionable steps toward unlocking your true potential. Act fast—this exclusive offer, using coupon code MG#20 for free access or a special discount, is only available for the first 20 customers as part of a promotional introduction. Start your transformational wellness journey today!
Your path to optimal wellness is just a click away. Uncover your wellness scores and unlock your full potential today!
To your health and success,
The e7D team.
Resources:
American Hospital Association. (n.d.). Suicide prevention in the health care workforce. American Hospital Association. Retrieved from https://www.aha.org/suicideprevention/health-care-workforce
BMJ Open. (2019). Deficiencies in healthcare before suicide and actions to improve after: Results of a national study. BMJ Open, 9(12), e032290. Retrieved from https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/9/12/e032290
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (n.d.). Suicide prevention | Health topics | Polaris | ADP for policy. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/policy/polaris/healthtopics/suicide/index.html
Frontiers in Psychiatry. (2018). The zero suicide model: Applying evidence-based suicide prevention practices to clinical care. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 9. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00033
National Institutes of Health. (2022). Suicide in healthcare workers: Determinants, challenges, and protective interventions. Frontiers in Psychology. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8850721/
National Institutes of Health. (2015). Caring for emergency department (ED) patients with suicidal thoughts and behaviors. Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 38(1), 25–40. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4724471
National Institutes of Health. (2019). Trust in health care: An evolving concept. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 34(12), 2448–2454. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6486232/
Polaris Group & CDC. (n.d.). Improving suicide prevention through evidence-based strategies: A systematic review. American Journal of Psychiatry. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2020.20060864
SHC Cares. (n.d.). The real cost of turnover in healthcare staffing. Retrieved from https://shccares.com/the-real-cost-of-turnover-in-healthcare-staffing/
International Association of Chiefs of Police. (n.d.). After a suicide in blue: A guide for enforcement agencies. Retrieved from https://www.theiacp.org/sites/default/files/244736_IACP_NOSI_AfterSuicide_p5%5B1%5D_0.pdf
Society for Human Resource Management. (n.d.). The real costs of recruitment. Retrieved from https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/hr-topics/talent-acquisition/pages/the-real-costs-of-recruitment.aspx
MedCognition. (n.d.). Healthcare employee training: What's it really costing us? Retrieved from https://medcognition.com/blog/healthcare-employee-training-whats-it-really-costing-us/
Comments